Part 5
Today's Muslim Population in China
It is extremely difficult to ascertain the number of Muslims there are in China today. Thus, at this time, any figure presented should be taken only as a best estimate. Care must be taken to distinguish clearly between facts on the one hand and assertions, possibilities, and hypotheses on the other.
In 1980, in the midst of the liberal mood of the "Four Modernisations" and the post "Gang of Four", post-Mao period, Beijing announced a new set of figures for the fifty-five ethnic groups that it currently identifies as "minority nationalities." Among these fifty-five minorities (whose total population Beijing states to be 55.8 million, or six percent of China's total population), ten are identified, among which Islam has been the prevailing religion. A tallying of the figures for these ten groups produces a total population of slightly more than thirteen million (13,152,200) or about 1.3 percent of the total Chinese population.
Beijing's general practice has been to avoid referring to these minority groups as Muslims per se, the rationale being that many members of the minority in question no longer "believe in religion". Nevertheless, this figure of about thirteen million may be taken as Beijing's present official position as to the total number of Muslims in China (excluding Taiwan province for which Beijing does not give statistics). Even this increase over the figure put forth by Beijing in 1953 is still unrealistically small, however, in view of the nearly one-hundred percent growth of the total Chinese population during the same period. Also, even if it were true that there were only ten million Muslims in 1953, it is highly unlikely that their rate of increase would have failed to keep up with that of the Han Chinese. Instead it is more likely that the Muslims would have surpassed the Han given that the minorities have not been obliged to conform to the rigid population control measures that the Chinese leadership has imposed upon the Han.
Government attempts to favor the minorities have included the establishment of "autonomous" minority adminstrative units at three levels: the region (comparable to a province and of which five have been designated), the prefecture (zhou), and the county (xian). The Muslim-inhabited areas that have been designated as autonomous regions, prefectures, and counties are shown in the following table.
To a great extent these territories are autonomous in name only. While the minority after which they are named does have considerable representation in local government and party organs, the Han generally retain ultimate control and pursue various colonising strategies designed to sinify the minorities and establish a strong Han presence. In no case is the "autonomous" unit inhabited only by the minority (or minorities) for which it is named and in some cases Han are in fact the majority. (This is even true, for example, of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region whose population is approximately only one-third Hui but two-thirds Han.)
As noted above, ten minorities have now been officially identified for which Islam has been the dominant religious tradition. As also noted, not all members of the ten minorities actually practice Islam. But Islam is so much a part of each of the ten ethnic identities that individual members of each group who, for one reason or another, do not practice Islam are still considered Muslim "by birth" or "by blood"; in nearly all cases, if members of any of these ten minorities do not practice Islam, then they do not practice any religion.
Each of China's ten Muslim minorities traces its descent to ancestors who were absorbed into China by Chinese territorial expansion or who migrated to China either for commercial purposes, as refugees from conflicts outside China, or to assist the Chinese court. Islam was not carried to China "by the sword" and, with minor exceptions, Muslims did not engage in proselytisation in China.
Nine of the ten Muslim minorities are of Central Asian derivation; they are the Uighur, Kazak, Dongxiang, Kyrgyz, Salar, Tajik, Uzbek, Bonan, and Tatar. Six of these nine live in what has traditionally been known as Eastern (or Chinese) Turkestan, territory that became a province of China (Xinjiang) only in 1884 but which constitutes one sixth of China's total land area; until only very recently these six Muslim groups made up well over ninety percent of Xinjiang's population.
Each of the nine Central Asian Muslim minorities still speaks its own native languages, all of which belong to the Altaic language family and are thus as different from Chinese as is English. Of the nine minorities, six (the Uighur, Kazak, Kyrgyz, Salar, Uzbek, and Tatar) speak Turkic languages which are similar to that spoken in Turkey and to those used throughout much of the former Soviet Union. Traditionally, when written, Arabic script was used for these peoples' languages although over the years both the former Soviet and Chinese governments have launched numerous campaigns to replace Arabic with other scripts. Four of the Turkic-speaking Muslim minorities represented in China - the Kazak, Kyrgyz, Uzbek, and Tatar - have, in fact, greater numbers of their members living in the former Soviet Union than in China and the first three of them also extend into Afghanistan. Two of China's six Turkic-speaking minorities (the Kazak and Kyrgyz), still maintain a pastoral nomadic herding mode of subsistence while four of the six (the Uighur, Uzbek, Tatar, and Salar), have long been sedentarised and are either agriculturists or urban oasis dwellers. Also in Xinjiang, and farthest away from China proper, are the Persian-speaking Tajik, a minority whose greatest numbers live across the border in Afghanistan and the former Soviet Union.
The two remaining Muslim groups of Central Asian origin are the Dongxiang and Bonan (also spelled Tunghsiang and Paoan respectively) of Gansu province, both of whom speak their own separate Mongolian language. Unlike other Mongols, who are pastoral herders, both the Dongxiang and Bonan have adopted sedentary agricultural patterns characteristic of the Han-influenced areas in which they live. The Dongxiang, like the Turkic Salar who also live in a more Han-influenced area than Xinjiang, have a long-standing reputation among Han for daring, fiercencess, and solidarity and played active parts in the Muslim rebellions that occurred up through the early twentieth century.
By an analysis of the mosque congregations in China we arrive at a higher total for the Chinese Muslim population. On the mainland of China according to the China Islamic Association there are 40,000 mosques. Traditionally a mosque is built by Muslim localities on demand, under the supervision of local Muslims. Conservatively speaking a mosque cannot be built and maintained by less than 500 Muslims in one locality; if we multiply the total number of mosques by 500 persons per mosque we arrive at a total of 20,000,000 Muslims in China in 1955, when this number of mosques are said to have existed. Yet we cannot use the 500 person per mosque as a mean average because in Peking, there are 42 mosques among a population of 80,000 Muslims which averages 2,000 Muslims under the jurisdiction of each mosque. This estimate of mosque do not even include the mosque used primarily by women who in many communities have their own mosques due to Islamic traditions. Taking these estimates into consideration the total Muslim population in China should not be less than 40 million.
Muslim Minorities in the People's Republic of China
MINORITY
LOCATION
LANGUAGE FAMILY
1953 CENSUS
1957 PEOPLE'S HANDBOOK
1961 NATIONALITIE IN CHINA
BEIJING REVIEW 1980
APPROX. AVG ANNUAL % GROWTH
Hui
All Provinces but especially Ningxia, Gansu, Xinjiang, Qinghai, Henan, Hebei
Sino Tibetan
3,559,350
3,550,000
3,934,335
6,490,000
2.3%
Uighur
Xinjiang
Altaic (Turkic)
3,640,125
3,640,000
3,901,205
5,480,000
1.6%
Kazak
Xinjiang, Gansu, Qinghai
Altaic (Turkic)
475,000
500,000
533,160
800,000
1.8%
Dongxiang
Gansu
Altaic (Mongolian)
150,000
159,345
190,000
0.8%
Kyrgyz
Xinjiang
Altaic (Turkic)
60,000
70,000
68,862
97,000
1%
Salar
Qinghai, Gansu
Altaic (Turkic)
30,000
31,923
56,000
2%
Tajik
Xinjiang
Indo Iranian
80,000
14,000
15,014
22,000
1.4%
Uzbek
Xinjiang
Altaic (Turkic)
13,000
13,000
11,557
7,500
2.4%
Bonan
Gansu
Altaic (Mongolian)
4,000
5,516
6,800
1.6%
Tatar
Xinjiang
Altaic (Turkic)
6,000
4,370
2,900
4.3%
Totals
7,827,475
7,977,000
8,665,287
13,152,200
Beijing Review Vol 23 #9 (March 3 1980), quoting figures based on 1978 statistics
Muslim Inhabited Areas
Designated as Autonomous Regions, Districts, and Counties.
MINORITY
PROVINCE
AUTONOMOUS AREAS
YEAR FOUNDED
Hui
Ningxia
Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region
1958
Gansu
Linxia Hui Autonomous Prefecture
Zhangjiaquan Hui Autonomous County1956
1955
Xinjiang
Changji Hui Autonomous Coutny
Yenqi Hui Autonomous County1954
1954
Guizhou
Weining Yi-Hui-Miao Autonomous County
1954
Hebei
Dachang Hui Autonomous County
Mengcum Hui Autonomous County1954
1954
Liaoning
Fouxian Hui Autonomous County
1957
Qinghai
Hualong Hui Autonomous County
Menyuan Hui Autonomous County1954
1953
Yunan
Weishan Yi-Hui Autonomous County
1960
Uighur
Xinjiang
Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region
1955
Kazak
Xinjiang
Ili Kazak Autonomous Prefecture
Barkol Kazak Autonomous County
Mulei Kazak Autonomous County1954
1954
1954
Gansu
Aksai Kazak Autonomous Region
1954
Qinghai
Haixa Mongol-Tibetan-Kazak Autonomous Prefecture
1954
Dongxiang
Gansu
Dongxiang Autonomous Region
1950
Kyrgyz
Xinjiang
Kizilsu Kyrgyz Autonomous Prefecture
1954
Salar
Qinghai
Xunhua Salar Autonomous Region
1954
Tajik
Xinjiang
Taxkorgan Tajik Autonomous Region
1954
Uzbek
Xinjiang
None
Bonan
Gansu, Qinghai
None
Tatar
Xinjiang
None